|
|||||||
| Date | Home | H Score | Away | A Score | Winner | ||
| 04/27/2024 | Penfield | 13 | Orchard Park | 6 | Penfield | ||
| 04/29/2023 | Orchard Park | 7 | Penfield | 8 | Penfield | ||
| 04/30/2022 | Penfield | 16 | Orchard Park | 4 | Penfield | ||
| 04/13/2019 | Orchard Park | 8 | Penfield | 10 | Penfield | ||
| 05/04/2018 | Penfield | 8 | Orchard Park | 4 | Penfield | ||
| 05/05/2017 | Orchard Park | 15 | Penfield | 10 | Orchard Park | ||
| 04/22/2016 | Penfield | 14 | Orchard Park | 4 | Penfield | ||
| 04/30/2015 | Orchard Park | 11 | Penfield | 7 | Orchard Park | ||
| 04/11/2014 | Penfield | 9 | Orchard Park | 6 | Penfield | ||
| 06/01/2013 | Penfield | 12 | Orchard Park | 11 | Penfield | ||
| 04/11/2013 | Orchard Park | 3 | Penfield | 10 | Penfield | ||
| 05/17/2012 | Penfield | 13 | Orchard Park | 8 | Penfield | ||
| 04/27/2011 | Orchard Park | 8 | Penfield | 9 | Penfield | ||
| 04/21/2009 | Orchard Park | 14 | Penfield | 2 | Orchard Park | ||
| 06/06/2006 | Orchard Park | 12 | Penfield | 11 | Orchard Park | ||
| 4 wins for Orchard Park vs 11 wins for Penfield | |||||||